User testing formats and methods
User testing formats generally fall into one of three buckets:
Moderated testing – a facilitator guides participants through test scenarios while observing their interactions.
Unmoderated testing – participants complete test scenarios independently.
Remote testing – participants test the product from their own environment and using their own devices. Remote testing can be moderated or unmoderated.
The specific user testing methods then available include:
A/B testing
Probably the most well-known in the world of digital products now! A/B testing involves presenting users with two versions of a product or feature and measuring which version performs better in terms of predefined metrics such as conversion rates or user engagement. This method is particularly useful for testing design variations or feature implementations, and is perfect for agile teams who want to get more real-time feedback. Where it falls down though is that it’s so good for understanding the ‘why’ behind the results and user behaviours.
Surveys and questionnaires
These can be used to gather feedback from a larger group of users about their experiences with the product. These methods are useful for collecting quantitative data and commentary on user satisfaction, preferences and demographics.
Eye tracking
Eye tracking is great for measuring where participants are looking on the screen while interacting with your product. This method provides insights into user attention and can help identify areas of the interface that may need improvement. On the flip side, it can be costly and take a long time to set up.
Think-aloud protocol
This involves asking participants to verbalise their thoughts and actions as they interact with the product. This method provides insights into users' decision-making processes and can help identify usability issues or confusion.
Heuristic evaluation
This format involves expert evaluators assessing the product against a set of usability principles or heuristics. While not strictly a user testing method, heuristic evaluation can help identify potential usability issues early in the design process.
User testing challenges and how to avoid them
As you can imagine, with some of the user testing methods and formats outlined above, there are certain challenges that these approaches can throw up. Nevertheless, the benefits to the overall success of your digital product far outweigh any negatives and, what’s more, if you’re armed with knowing what the challenges are, you can do your best to avoid them!
Limited resources and/or time constraints
Depending on the user testing method you choose to run, it can require significant resources in terms of time, budget and personnel.
To avoid this, make sure you:
Prioritise the key issues or features you want to test.
Plan and schedule user testing early in the development process.
Explore cost-effective alternatives such as remote or unmoderated testing.
Recruitment of participants
It can be challenging to recruit participants who accurately represent the target audience of your digital product. But without diverse and representative participants, the feedback gathered may not accurately reflect the needs and preferences of your actual user base.
To avoid this:
Clearly define the characteristics of your target audience and develop screening criteria for participants.
Use multiple recruitment channels.
Offer incentives or compensation.
Bias in facilitation or interpretation
The presence of a facilitator or moderator during user testing sessions can introduce bias, affecting the way participants behave or the interpretation of their feedback. Additionally, researchers may unintentionally interpret feedback in a way that aligns with their own assumptions or preferences.
To avoid this:
Train facilitators or moderators to remain neutral and objective.
Standardise testing protocols and materials.
Use multiple evaluators to review and interpret the findings.
By addressing these challenges proactively and implementing strategies to mitigate them, you can enhance the reliability of your user testing efforts, ensuring you reap the benefits for your digital product launch. What’s more, by incorporating user testing at key stages in your development process, you can iteratively refine and improve the product based on real user feedback, leading to a more successful and user-friendly final product.
Whether it’s planning your user testing strategy or running the testing with your customers, one great option to ensure you get the most out of it is to entrust it with an expert partner.
If you’d like to hear how the Adrenalin team have helped other global brands with their user testing stages, then get in touch.
And for more insights into digital product and design strategy, be sure to subscribe to our newsletter.